Lily Hates Me: A Love Story — Chapter 55

I whimpered as he inserted his fingers into my core and slowly slipped them in and out. It was agonizing. Agonizingly amazing. I reached out and gripped his back.

"See what you've been missing?" Tony smirked.

Shut up Tony, you are ruining it.

"You sure are tight," he whispered in my ears.

Ugh...I felt hot inside. An unfamiliar feeling was building up inside me and it was getting harder and harder for me to suppress my moans.

"You are clenching up on my fingers. Are gonna cum?" he grinned.

"Ahh...I don't know you asshole!" I cried.

He laughed. "So much attitude on a girl who is at my mercy. I'll tell you what, if you ask me nicely I'll let you cum," he said and kissed my nose.

"I'm not asking," I winced.

"Okay then I'll just remove my fingers and you go on with your life," his eyes were twinkling with mischief and I wanted to kill him.

"N...no...you devil just finish it," I avoided his eyes.

"Alright princess, I would've done it anyway. I'm not that cruel," he laughed.

I bit my lips as he moved his fingers faster and harder. I could feel my insides clench again.

"Tony...it feels so good," I gasped as he covered my breast with his mouth and sucked on my nipple at the same time he was fingering me.

I couldn't hold back my scream as the intense pleasure hit me and I came all over his fingers.

I couldn't move for a few moments. I needed time to process. My body felt like I was floating.

"Don't fall asleep, that was just a warm-up. We haven't even gotten to the main event yet," he smirked.

What...main event?

He unzipped his pants to show exactly what he meant and I wanted to cry. That thing is going to break me in half, I thought.

"Don't look so horrified," he chuckled.

I shivered violently as he rubbed the tip between my legs. I closed my eyes and waited for the pain. But nothing happened.

I opened my eyes and found Tony staring at me intently. Is he gonna do it or not!

He cleared his throat. "I thought you were kidding when you said you never had sex before," he said.

"Kiddi-....why would I kid about that?" I asked.

"I don't know Summer. You are always joking around. I thought you said that so I wouldn't force myself on you," he said.

"Well that didn't stop you," I pointed at his erection.

"I...well I can't. We should stop here," he said.

WHAT!

"What do you mean?" I whined.

"I don't have sex with Virgins. Too much drama," he said and proceeded to get off of me but I grabbed him by his side and pushed him down on the bed.

"Jesus...Summer! What are you doing?" he gasped as I straddled him.

"Listen here, you jerk. I was doing great resisting you and YOU pushed me to this point. So you better finish what you started or I'll kill you motherfucker," I was fuming.

"Damn are you that despera...OW!" he yelped as I smacked him on the face, with bruises and all. "So violent," he laughed.

"Are you going to be my first or not?" I sighed. At this point, I only wanted him and no one else.

"Alright, you win," he said quietly laid me on the bed. He grabbed a condom and put it on himself then hovered over me. "I'm not a nice guy you know. You'll regret wasting your first time with me."

His eyes were dark. I reached over and touched his lips. He leaned down and kissed my parted mouth. I felt his warmth spread through my body as he pressed against me.

I gasped loudly as he suddenly thrust into me. My eyes started to tear up from the pain.

"Sorry, just relax your body and it'll get better soon," he said and placed small kisses on my face.

Ah the gentle Tony who took care of the drunk me is back. I hope he stays.

He started to move slowly. "You okay, baby girl?" his voice was low and gentle. I wrapped my arms around him and nodded in response.

He thrust into me a few more times before he came and collapsed on top of me.

"I'm sorry. I tried to make it quick because I didn't want to hurt you anymore," he said and buried his face in my hair.

"Why do you care? I thought you were a bad person," I giggled.

"I don't like hurting girls. Not like this anyway. That's why I told you I don't do virgins," he said.

I snuggled against him. Maybe he was not as bad as I thought.

Boy, was I wrong.

"So...um...I gotta go but thanks," Tony said awkwardly before he left.

"Ew...don't thank me for sex. That's just weird!" I said.

He chuckled. "Fine. I'll see you at school then?" he said and scratched his neck. Why is he acting all shy? Where's the cocky bad boy Tony?

"Yeah," I said.

I thought I would regret giving my first time and possibly selling my soul for someone like Tony but I felt...kind of happy? He was not at all like what I expected in bed. He was sweet and gentle and took good care of me and made me feel good. I felt like it was more than just a physical attraction. I actually like Anthony Dean!

But did he feel the same way? Only one way to find out, I thought.

The next day at school, I looked for him. We should talk about things and figure out what exactly was going on between us, I thought. I found him standing outside, and what do you know...with a girl!

A redhead I didn't know pressed up against him and he looked like he was enjoying himself. I gave him my body and this bitch already looking at another target?

"Ahem..." I cleared my throat to get their attention.

"Oh hey Summer," Tony said casually. "You know Destiny, right?"

"No, I don't know Destiny. Can I talk to you for a second?" I asked. I looked at Destiny and glared. "Alone?"

Destiny gave me a sly smile and walked away. But not before pecking him on the lips. Oh someone is going down today and it's not going to be pretty!

"What can I do for you Summer?" Tony asked. This asshole.

"What the hell do you think you are doing? We slept together last night!" I exclaimed.

"So?" he shrugged.

"What do you mean, so? Didn't last night mean anything to you?" I asked. I already knew what was happening. This idiot used me!

"Look Summer, you are a pretty girl and I had fun with you last night. But that's all it was. We had fun. I don't like staying with a girl after sleeping with her or she gets too attached. I figured you already knew that and wanted to have sex with me anyway. So are we cool?" he smirked and punched my shoulder playfully.

OHH HELL NOOOO!

I grabbed his collar and roughly pulled him closer. "Listen here asshole. I am not one of your sluts you can use then forget about. I slept with you because I liked you. I can't believe I actually liked you!" I was angry and hurt at the same time. Mostly angry. I should've known better. He was a known asshole. I should've seen this coming and yet, I fell into his trap.

"Whoa, take it easy, Phillips. What do you want from me? You want me to be your boyfriend? Not gonna happen," his eyes were cold and hard.

I let him go. "You are not going to get away with this Anthony Dean. You messed with the wrong girl. I will make you sorry," I threatened him.

"Ooooh I am sooo scared! What are you gonna do? Ask one of your exes to beat me up again?" he chuckled.

No, not this time. I need to be smart about this and destroy Anthony Dean.

"Mark my words. You'll be sorry!" I glared at him.

"Counting on it!" he grinned.